Pavel Vrublevsky lost almost half a million dollars in the rent and renovation of the Shubins' house after the hearing in the Odintsovo City Court of the Moscow Region. The court considered the claim of businessman Pavel Vrublevsky and his wife against Vladimir Shubin for renting a house located in the village of Nikolina Gora, Moscow Region.
As a source told Lenta.ru, today, on November 17, the Shubins were hospitalized from the Green Wind SNT, also located near Nikolina Gora, to one of the clinics near Moscow with a diagnosis of COVID-19. In a conversation with a Lenta.ru correspondent, Svetlana confirmed the fact of her illness, refusing to comment further. Vladimir denied the diagnosis of coronavirus. “We were not sent to any hospital, we do not have any coronavirus,” he stressed. But, as one of the residents of the village told “Lente.ru”, Vladimir Shubin returned home in the same ambulance in which he was taken away. True, according to the source, then he was taken away again.
Pavel Vrublevsky is a famous businessman: the founder of the ChronoPay payment company, the RNP.com fund, the first investor in habr.com. Vladimir and Svetlana Shubins are the owners of a car service, a granite workshop on Varshavskoye Highway and an elite house on Nikolina Gora, which they lease.
Yesterday, on November 16, the Odintsovo City Court of the Moscow Region considered the claim from Pavel Vrublevsky to Vladimir and Svetlana Shubin. According to Vrublevsky, in 2010 he and his family rented a house from Shubin for 10 thousand dollars a month. Then the price was reduced to $ 5 thousand.
Shubin tried several times to break the lease, but changed his mind. Then the Vrublevskys wanted to buy a house, but the deal fell through on the initiative of the owner. It turned out that the garage with the boiler room was built illegally, so the deal was initially impossible to conclude. “My guess is that everything is connected exclusively with the fact that he did not pay taxes,” Pavel Vrublevsky told the “360” TV channel. – He is a tax resident of the United States, and by law he must pay taxes here and there. In this situation, it is impossible to engage in hiring, because taxes eat up 80 percent of the profits. ”
According to Vrublevsky, during this time he lost almost half a million dollars on renting and repairing a house. In court, he tried to get the lease to be recognized as “a deal made under the influence of deception.” He was denied this claim, and the Shubins' claim for eviction was satisfied. The court appointed an amount of 450 thousand rubles for each month of non-execution of the decision from the entry into force – that is, after the appeal has passed.
The applicants are satisfied with the court's decision. The fact is that the Shubins' side, which presented a debt of 150 thousand dollars, did not demand this money. Pavel Vrublevsky's lawyers, in a conversation with Lenta.ru, noted that most likely the Shubins did not take into account that a copy of their testimony was officially being handed over to the applicant. According to them, after that Vrublevsky once again turned to the prosecutor's office.
“The main stumbling block in the debriefing of flights with Shubin is precisely the criminal statements against him on the fact of obvious fraud,” Pavel Vrublevsky himself noted in a conversation with Lenta.ru. – Without criminal cases, it is extremely difficult to prove deception, which is a criminal offense, in a civil court. But the OVD Uspenskoe, despite the material returned to them twice from the prosecutor's office, simply blinded, there is no other way to call it. I think I made this story public too late. ” According to him, the last straw for him was the Shubins' attempt to demand in court the very 150 thousand dollars that they allegedly did not receive. “But they themselves previously confirmed the same money, as received during the check by the” blind “operatives of the OVD Uspenskoe, – Vrublevsky is indignant. “It was already overtly frank, and I posted the whole story on my blog.”
Shubin himself, when asked by the journalist of Lenta.ru, how can he explain that in the OVD Uspenskoe he indicated one amount as received, and in court declared the same amount as not received, said that in court he indicated only “recognized money”.
“In fact, it is very simple, he [Vrublevsky] lives, the courts are going, he does not pay, this money that he did not pay in addition, money that is recognized, for which there are documents from which taxes have been paid, then they all seem to be, but, the fact that he did not pay extra, so the court will figure it out, ”Shubin told Lente.ru. Apparently, he meant non-cash payments. Lenta.ru failed to find out exactly what “recognized money” is.
In court, Shubin filed a debt of 150 thousand US dollars for housekeeping payments for 2021. However, after the publication of Vrublevsky's blog, Shubin did not declare these 150 thousand dollars in his claims, although he had previously confirmed it as received in cash at the OVD Uspenskoye, which is clearly evident from his testimony, which Vrublevsky also published on his blog.
“ Thus, the court simply satisfied the requirement for failure to comply with the court's decision on eviction, in fact, to pay the rent, which we already paid – and then after the decision entered into legal force, that is, after the appeal. Simply put, Shubin will definitely not get more money from me, ”said Pavel Vrublevsky.